$350 Million, Eleven Years, and a Card Issuer: What the Amex AML Orders Teach Every Compliance Team

October 12, 2026 By FinCheck

The OCC assessed a $350 million civil money penalty and issued a cease-and-desist order against American Express National Bank, and the Federal Reserve issued its own order against the parent company and its travel-related services subsidiary. The headline number is large, but the more important story is where the failures sat: not in a high-risk correspondent book, but in a card and charge business that many institutions still treat as low risk for money laundering.

For compliance leaders at banks, FinTechs, money services businesses and gaming operators, the orders read less like an outlier and more like a checklist of how a mature program quietly drifts out of alignment with its real risk.

What the regulators found

Based on published summaries of the orders, the cited conduct ran from roughly 2014 to 2025. The OCC found the bank had not maintained a BSA/AML program reasonably designed to assure and monitor compliance. Reported deficiencies include a risk assessment centred on the bank’s narrow deposit products rather than its credit and charge card activity, substantial gaps in customer identification, and monitoring failures that produced untimely, missed or incomplete suspicious activity reports.

Reports also describe about $13 billion in suspected trade-based money laundering moving through the bank, including through accounts connected to insiders, and a program that was not historically supported with adequate resources. The bank neither admitted nor denied the findings. Please verify details against the OCC and Federal Reserve releases before relying on them, as this analysis draws on secondary summaries.

What the orders require

The remedial list is instructive because it mirrors what examiners now expect from any institution. It includes a rebuilt enterprise risk assessment covering all products, customer types and insiders, refreshed at least every twelve months; correction of customer files with missing or inaccurate due diligence; monitoring across every business unit with risk-based limits; and an independent consultant to run a SAR look-back that the OCC can expand.

The Federal Reserve order goes further on governance, requiring a demonstration of senior management accountability, an enterprise-wide plan that reaches network, ATM and other third-party partners, a sanctions plan with OFAC screening procedures, and cooperation with investigations of individuals. Neither order has an end date, and the bank remains exposed to further penalties.

Four lessons for compliance teams

Risk assessment must follow the product, not the charter. When the assessment describes the products an institution used to offer rather than the ones that drive its volume, every downstream control inherits the blind spot. Test whether your assessment would still make sense if you removed the org chart.

Customer identification gaps compound quietly. Monitoring is only as good as the customer data behind it. Incomplete or inaccurate due diligence files make alerts unreliable and make SAR narratives thin.

Insider-linked accounts need their own controls. Accounts tied to employees or affiliates sit outside normal behavioural baselines and deserve explicit monitoring and escalation paths.

Third parties are part of your program. The Federal Reserve’s focus on partners and network participants echoes the broader regulatory direction on sponsor banks and vendors. Outsourced activity does not outsource accountability.

Why this matters beyond banks. Many non-bank businesses rely on sponsor banks, processors and card programs for their rails. When a bank-level order demands enterprise-wide plans covering partners and third parties, the expectations flow downstream through contract terms, audits and onboarding questionnaires. FinTechs, MSBs and gaming operators should expect more detailed requests for risk assessments, monitoring evidence and SAR governance from their banking partners over the coming quarters. Treat those requests as an opportunity to demonstrate maturity rather than a burden.

FinCheck’s perspective and way forward

The lesson is not that card issuers are uniquely weak. It is that scale, growth and a reputation for low-risk customers can mask exactly the typologies, such as trade-based laundering, that monitoring was never tuned to detect. The same dynamic applies to money transmitters, payment facilitators, crypto businesses and sweepstakes and social casino platforms, where product mix shifts faster than the risk assessment is updated.

A practical way forward starts with an enterprise risk assessment refresh anchored on actual transaction flows by product, followed by a customer due diligence file-quality sample, a back-testing of monitoring scenarios against typologies that matter for your business, and an independent review of SAR timeliness. Document the resourcing decisions, because regulators increasingly treat underinvestment as a finding in itself.

FinCheck supports institutions with independent AML program reviews, enterprise risk assessments, fractional CCO and BSA Officer support, transaction monitoring tuning and SAR quality reviews across FinTech, MSB, crypto and gaming clients.

Is your program tested against how you actually operate?

If your risk assessment, customer file quality or SAR timeliness has not been independently tested recently, now is the moment. Message FinCheck to arrange a confidential program health check. A short, independent review today is far less costly than a look-back ordered by a regulator tomorrow, and it gives your board and your banking partners documented evidence that the program matches the business you actually run. Start with the highest-volume product, because that is where examiners will start.